Skip to main content

Main menu

  • HOME
  • CONTENT
    • Early Release
    • Featured
    • Current Issue
    • Issue Archive
    • Blog
    • Collections
    • Podcast
  • TOPICS
    • Cognition and Behavior
    • Development
    • Disorders of the Nervous System
    • History, Teaching and Public Awareness
    • Integrative Systems
    • Neuronal Excitability
    • Novel Tools and Methods
    • Sensory and Motor Systems
  • ALERTS
  • FOR AUTHORS
  • ABOUT
    • Overview
    • Editorial Board
    • For the Media
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Feedback
  • SUBMIT

User menu

Search

  • Advanced search
eNeuro
eNeuro

Advanced Search

 

  • HOME
  • CONTENT
    • Early Release
    • Featured
    • Current Issue
    • Issue Archive
    • Blog
    • Collections
    • Podcast
  • TOPICS
    • Cognition and Behavior
    • Development
    • Disorders of the Nervous System
    • History, Teaching and Public Awareness
    • Integrative Systems
    • Neuronal Excitability
    • Novel Tools and Methods
    • Sensory and Motor Systems
  • ALERTS
  • FOR AUTHORS
  • ABOUT
    • Overview
    • Editorial Board
    • For the Media
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Feedback
  • SUBMIT
PreviousNext
Research ArticleResearch Article: Theory/New Concepts, Development

Poor Concordance of Floxed Sequence Recombination in Single Neural Stem Cells: Implications for Cell Autonomous Studies

Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby
eNeuro 20 February 2020, 7 (2) ENEURO.0470-19.2020; https://doi.org/10.1523/ENEURO.0470-19.2020
Tyler Joseph Dause
1Deptartment of Psychology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
Elizabeth Diana Kirby
1Deptartment of Psychology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210
2Deptartment of Neuroscience, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210
3The Chronic Brain Injury Program, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210
  • Find this author on Google Scholar
  • Find this author on PubMed
  • Search for this author on this site
  • Article
  • Figures & Data
  • Info & Metrics
  • eLetters
  • PDF
Loading

Article Figures & Data

Figures

  • Tables
  • Extended Data
  • Figure1
    • Download figure
    • Open in new tab
    • Download powerpoint
  • Figure 1.
    • Download figure
    • Open in new tab
    • Download powerpoint
    Figure 1.

    Theoretical probabilistic models reveal potential for error in a common paradigm for testing cell autonomous gene function. A, Cell autonomous function of genes is frequently investigated using a cell-specific Cre-loxP system where expression of reporter protein from a stop-floxed reporter construct is assumed to reliably indicate target gene recombination within a single cell. Here, a generic schematic of the genetics used and assumptions employed in this common paradigm are shown. B, The probabilities of true and false reporter signals are shown for three hypothetical scenarios with 100 target cells for visualization. All three scenarios assume an experiment where gene recombination occurs only in the presence of Cre, reporter protein expression is observed in 50% of target cells [P(Rr) = 0.5], and reporter recombination is greater than or equal to target gene recombination [P(Rr) ≥ P(Tr)]. The numbers in red boxes represent given values that are then used to determine the remaining probabilities. The “theoretical ideal” represents an ideal scenario where reporter gene recombination and target gene recombination overlap perfectly. The “different efficiency, max concordance” scenario shows a case where target gene recombines with less efficiency than the reporter, but shows the maximum possible concordance with reporter recombination given that constraint. The “different efficiency, < max concordance” scenario shows a case where target gene recombination is mildly less efficient than reporter gene recombination and concordance is moderately suboptimal, with 75% of target recombined cells also showing reporter recombination. In the hypothetical deviations from ideal, the probability of reporter expression accurately predicting target gene recombination [P(Tr|Rr)] is 0.5 and 0.6, respectively. These examples demonstrate that even mild deviation from ideal can introduce possible substantial error in using reporter gene recombination as an indicator of target gene recombination in the same cell. See also Extended Data Figure 1-1. Figure Contributions: Elizabeth Diana Kirby developed theoretical models and made figures.

  • Figure 2.
    • Download figure
    • Open in new tab
    • Download powerpoint
    Figure 2.

    Recombination-dependent fluorescent reporter gene expression is correlated over the whole SGZ, but frequently fails to co-localize. A, A schematic of the transgenic mouse model employed in our experiments where we combined NestinCreERT2 mice Rosa-stop-floxed-EYFP and Rosa-CAG-stop-floxed-tdTomato mice. Mice were then submitted to three TAM administration conditions, 3D short (B), 3D long (C), and 5D (D; top, representative timeline of TAM injections and recovery; bottom, immunostaining of EYFP and tdTomato in SGZ; scale bars: 100 μm). E, EYFP+ and tdTomato+ DG percent area was compared by two-way ANOVA in 3D short, 3D long, and 5D mice. Tukey’s post hoc comparison within reporter type; *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001 versus 5D. F, EYFP+ and tdTomato+ DG percent area were correlated in all mice. R,p Pearson’s correlation. G, Representative orthogonal images: immunostaining and imaging of EYFP+, tdTomato+, and EYFP+tdTomato+ cells in the SGZ. Scale bar: 20 μm. H, EYFP+ colocalization in tdTomato+ area (H) and tdTomato+ colocalization in EYFP+ area (I) were compared with theoretical 100% colocalization; n = 3 mice per group. Data are shown as mean ± SEM; *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, ***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001. Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran experiments and analyzed data. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figure.

  • Figure 3.
    • Download figure
    • Open in new tab
    • Download powerpoint
    Figure 3.

    Recombination-dependent fluorescent reporter gene expression within RGLs and IPCs frequently fails to co-localize in the same cells. A, SGZ RGLs were identified by immunostaining of EYFP, tdTomato, and GFAP. Scale bars: 20 μm. Arrow head = EYFP+/tdTomato– RGL. Arrow = EYFP–/tdTomato+ RGL. Chevron = EYFP+/tdTomato+ RGL. B, SGZ IPCs were identified by immunostaining of EYFP, tdTomato and Ki-67. Scale bars: 20 μm. Arrow head = EYFP+/tdTomato– IPC. Arrow = EYFP–/tdTomato+ IPC. Chevron = EYFP+/tdTomato+ IPC. Density (C) and percentage (D) of SGZ GFAP+ RGLs coexpressing EYFP only(EYFP), tdTomato only(tdTom), EYFP+ and tdTomato+ (both), or neither are shown. Density (E) and percentage (F) of SGZ Ki67+ IPCs coexpressing EYFP, tdTom, both, or neither are shown; n = 3 mice per group. Data are shown as mean ± SEM. Density represented as cells per area, scale × 10−4. See also Extended Data Figure 3-1. Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran experiments and analyzed data. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figure.

  • Figure 4.
    • Download figure
    • Open in new tab
    • Download powerpoint
    Figure 4.

    Using expression of one reporter to predict expression of the other results in high false signals similarly across TAM protocols. A, The mean observed recombination frequencies from the 5D TAM group are represented here as reporter expression in 100 hypothetical target cells, either RGLs or IPCs. The probabilities of true and false signals are given as if tdTomato expression is being used to predict EYFP expression. B, The percent of RGLs and IPCs combined (total NSPCs) that show recombination in both reporter genes (true +) or neither (true –) is shown for three TAM groups. C, The total true signal between the three TAM groups is shown; n = 3 mice per group. Data shown are mean ± SEM; *p < 0.05 determined by two-way ANOVA. See also Extended Data Figures 4-1, 4-2. Figure Contributions: Elizabeth Diana Kirby performed statistical analyses and made figures.

Tables

  • Figures
  • Extended Data
    • View popup
    Table 1

    Primary and secondary antibodies

    Primary antibodyVendor/ product no.DilutionSecondaryVendor/product no.Dilution
    Rabbit anti-mCherryAbcam ab1674531:500Donkey anti-Rabbit IgG (H+L) highly cross-adsorbed secondary antibody, AlexaFluor 555ThermoFisher Scientific
    A-31572
    1:500
    HoechstFisher 333421:2000N/AN/AN/A
    Goat
    Anti-GFP antibody
    Abcam Ab66731:1000Donkey anti-Goat IgG (H+L) cross-adsorbed secondary antibody, AlexaFluor 488Fisher A-110551:500
    Mouse
    Anti-glial fibrillary acidic protein, clone GA5 (GFAP)
    EMD Millipore
    MAB360
    1:1000Donkey anti-mouse IgG (H+L) highly cross-adsorbed secondary antibody, Alexa Fluor 647Fisher A-315711:500
    Rat
    anti-Ki-67 monoclonal antibody
    Invitrogen
    14-5698-82
    1:500AlexaFluor 647 AffiniPure donkey anti-Rat IgG (H+L) (712-605-153)Jackson ImmunoResearch
    712-605-153
    1:500
    • View popup
    Table 2

    Statistics table

    EYFP and tdTomato DG percentage area comparison
    TAM administrationnTestComparisonStatisticPSignificant
    2E 3D Short3Two-way ANOVATAM × reporterF(2,6) = 8.8800.0161Yes*
    2E 3D Long3TAMF(2,6) = 11.320.0092Yes**
    2E 5D3ReporterF(1,6) = 14.010.0096Yes**
    SubjectF(6,6) = 12.520.0036Yes**
    EYFPtdTomato
    Post hoc ComparisonsAdjusted PSignificantAdjusted PSignificant
    Tukey’s multiple comparisons 3D short vs 3D long≥0.9999No0.9976No
    3D short vs 5D0.0009Yes***0.0274Yes*
    3D long vs 5D0.0009Yes***0.0308Yes*
    EYFP and tdTomato DG percentage area correlation
    FigureTAM administrationnTestStatisticPSignificant
    2F All9Pearson's Correlationr(8) = 0.91570.0005Yes***
    EYFP+ percentage area colocalization with tdTomato+ area
    TAM administrationnTestStatisticPSignificant
    2H 3D Short3One-sample t test w/ comparison to 100%t(2) = 35.870.0008Yes***
    2H 3D Long3t(2) = 13.150.0057Yes**
    2H 5D3t(2) = 15.360.0042Yes**
    tdTomato+ percentage area colocalization with EYFP+ area
    FigureTAM administrationnTestStatisticPSignificant
    2I 3D Short3One-sample t test w/ comparison to 100%t(2) = 119.70.0001Yes****
    2I 3D Long3t(2) = 10.400.0091Yes**
    2I 5D3t(2) = 11.270.0078Yes**
    DG percentage of NSPCs with True+ Signal
    FigureTAM administrationnTestComparisonStatisticPSignificant
    4B 3D Short3Two-way ANOVATrue signal × TamF(2,6) = 6.0840.0360Yes*
    4B 3D Long3True signalF(1,6) = 3.2150.1231No
    4B 5D3TAMF(2,6) = 3.2010.1132No
    SubjectF(6,6) = 0.028080.9998No
    Post hocComparisonsAdjusted PSignificant
    Tukey’s multiple comparisons3D short vs 3D long0.8875No
    3D short vs 5D0.0225Yes*
    3D long vs 5D0.0516No
    DG percentage of NSPCs with True−Signal
    FigureTAM administrationnTestComparisonStatisticPSignificant
    4B 3D Short3Two-way ANOVATrue−Signal × TAMF(2,6) = 6.0840.0360Yes*
    4B 3D Long3True−SignalF(1,6) = 3.2150.1231No
    4B 5D3TAMF(2,6) = 3.2010.1132No
    SubjectF(6,6) = 0.028080.9998No
    Post hocComparisonsAdjusted PSignificant
    Tukey’s multiple comparisons3D short vs 3D long0.9389No
    3D short vs 5D0.0328Yes*
    3D long vs 5D0.0179Yes*
    DG percentage of NSPCs with True ± Signal
    FigureTAM administrationnTestStatisticPSignificant
    4C 3D Short3One-way ANOVAF(2,6) = 3.2010.1132No
    4C 3D Long3F(2,6) = 3.2010.1132No
    4C 5D3F(2,6) = 3.2010.1132No
    • *p < 0.05, **p < 0.01,***p < 0.001, ****p < 0.0001.

Extended Data

  • Figures
  • Tables
  • Supplementary Extended Data Table 2-1

    Main Figures Raw Data. Download Table 2-1, DOCX file.

  • Supplementary Extended Data Table 2-2

    Extended Data Figures Raw Data and Statistics. Download Table 2-2, DOCX file.

  • Extended Data Figure 1-1

    Equation derivation for true and false signal probabilities. A, Assuming reporter recombination is greater than or equal to target gene recombination [P(Rr) ≥ P(Tr)], probability of total true signal is derived using standard conditional and unconditional probability formulas. B–D, Application of the equations in A to the scenarios described in Figure 1B are shown in full detail. Figure Contributions: Elizabeth Diana Kirby developed theoretical models. Download Figure 1-1, TIF file.

  • Extended Data Figure 2-1

    Comparison of oil- and TAM-injected adult NestinCreERT2;Rosa(EYFP/tdTom) mice. A, Immunostaining in the adult DG shows that oil administration does not stimulate expression of either reporter gene. B, TAM administration induces robust recombination-dependent expression of both EYFP and tdTomato in the SGZ. Scale bars: 100 μm. Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran TAM experiments and tissue staining. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figures. Download Figure 2-1, TIF file.

  • Extended Data Figure 3-1

    Cell-specific fluorescent reporter recombination frequency and correlation. A, Percent of EYFP+ or tdTomato+/GFAP+ RGLs were compared in 3D short, 3D long, and 5D mice. B, Correlation of percent of GFAP+ RGLs that express EYFP and tdTomato in all mice. C, Percent of EYFP+ or tdTomato+ IPCs were compared in 3D short, 3D long, and 5D mice. D, Correlation of percent of Ki67+ IPCs that express EYFP and tdTomato in all mice; n = 3 mice per group. Data are shown as mean ± SEM; *p < 0.05, determined by two-way ANOVA (A, C) or Pearson’s correlation (B, D). Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran experiments and analyzed data. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figures. Download Figure 3-1, TIF file.

  • Extended Data Figure 4-1

    Effects of cell type and TAM protocol on accuracy of using expression of one reporter to predict the other. A, The mean observed recombination frequencies from the 3D short (left) and 3D long (right) groups are represented here as reporter expression in 100 hypothetical target cells, either RGLs or IPCs. The probabilities of true and false signals are given as if tdTomato expression is being used to predict EYFP expression. B, The percent of GFAP+ RGL cells that show recombination in both reporter genes (true +) or neither (true –) is shown for three TAM groups. C, The total true signal (+ and –) in GFAP+ RGL cells for the three TAM groups is shown. D, The percent of Ki67+ IPCs that show recombination in both reporter genes (true +) or neither (true –) is shown for three TAM groups. E, The total true signal (+ and –) in Ki67+ IPCs for the three TAM groups is shown; n = 3 mice per group. Data shown are mean ± SEM; *p < 0.05, determined by two-way ANOVA. Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran experiments and analyzed data. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figures. Download Figure 4-1, TIF file.

  • Extended Data Figure 4-2

    Fluorescent reporter recombination and colocalization in SVZ NSPCs. A, Immunostaining of EYFP, tdTomato in SVZ NSPCs. Scale bars: 100 μm. Arrowhead = EYFP+/tdTomato– NSPC. Arrow = EYFP–/tdTomato+ NSPC. Chevron = EYFP+/tdTomato+ NSPC. B, Correlation of EYFP+ and tdTomato+ SVZ percent area in all mice. C, Comparison of EYFP+ colocalization in tdTomato+ area to theoretical 100% colocalization. D, Comparison of tdTomato+ colocalization in EYFP+ area to theoretical 100% colocalization; n = 9 mice. Data are shown as mean ± SEM; ****p < 0.0001 determined by Pearson’s correlation (B) or one-sample t test against a theoretical 100% (C, D). Figure Contributions: Tyler Joseph Dause ran experiments and analyzed data. Tyler Joseph Dause and Elizabeth Diana Kirby made figure. Download Figure 4-2, TIF file.

Back to top

In this issue

eneuro: 7 (2)
eNeuro
Vol. 7, Issue 2
March/April 2020
  • Table of Contents
  • Index by author
  • Ed Board (PDF)
Email

Thank you for sharing this eNeuro article.

NOTE: We request your email address only to inform the recipient that it was you who recommended this article, and that it is not junk mail. We do not retain these email addresses.

Enter multiple addresses on separate lines or separate them with commas.
Poor Concordance of Floxed Sequence Recombination in Single Neural Stem Cells: Implications for Cell Autonomous Studies
(Your Name) has forwarded a page to you from eNeuro
(Your Name) thought you would be interested in this article in eNeuro.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Print
View Full Page PDF
Citation Tools
Poor Concordance of Floxed Sequence Recombination in Single Neural Stem Cells: Implications for Cell Autonomous Studies
Tyler Joseph Dause, Elizabeth Diana Kirby
eNeuro 20 February 2020, 7 (2) ENEURO.0470-19.2020; DOI: 10.1523/ENEURO.0470-19.2020

Citation Manager Formats

  • BibTeX
  • Bookends
  • EasyBib
  • EndNote (tagged)
  • EndNote 8 (xml)
  • Medlars
  • Mendeley
  • Papers
  • RefWorks Tagged
  • Ref Manager
  • RIS
  • Zotero
Respond to this article
Share
Poor Concordance of Floxed Sequence Recombination in Single Neural Stem Cells: Implications for Cell Autonomous Studies
Tyler Joseph Dause, Elizabeth Diana Kirby
eNeuro 20 February 2020, 7 (2) ENEURO.0470-19.2020; DOI: 10.1523/ENEURO.0470-19.2020
Twitter logo Facebook logo Mendeley logo
  • Tweet Widget
  • Facebook Like
  • Google Plus One

Jump to section

  • Article
    • Visual Abstract
    • Abstract
    • Significance Statement
    • Introduction
    • Materials and Methods
    • Results
    • Discussion
    • Footnotes
    • References
    • Synthesis
    • Author Response
  • Figures & Data
  • Info & Metrics
  • eLetters
  • PDF

Keywords

  • adult neurogenesis
  • cell autonomous
  • CreERT2 recombinase
  • hippocampus
  • neural stem cells
  • subventricular zone

Responses to this article

Respond to this article

Jump to comment:

No eLetters have been published for this article.

Related Articles

Cited By...

More in this TOC Section

Research Article: Theory/New Concepts

  • Decoding Task-Specific Cognitive States with Slow, Directed Functional Networks in the Human Brain
  • Shunting Inhibition Improves Synchronization in Heterogeneous Inhibitory Interneuronal Networks with Type 1 Excitability Whereas Hyperpolarizing Inhibition Is Better for Type 2 Excitability
Show more Research Article: Theory/New Concepts

Development

  • Decoding Task-Specific Cognitive States with Slow, Directed Functional Networks in the Human Brain
  • Shunting Inhibition Improves Synchronization in Heterogeneous Inhibitory Interneuronal Networks with Type 1 Excitability Whereas Hyperpolarizing Inhibition Is Better for Type 2 Excitability
  • Deletion of endocannabinoid synthesizing enzyme DAGLα in Pcp2-positive cerebellar Purkinje cells decreases depolarization-induced short-term synaptic plasticity, reduces social preference, and heightens anxiety
Show more Development

Subjects

  • Development
  • Home
  • Alerts
  • Follow SFN on BlueSky
  • Visit Society for Neuroscience on Facebook
  • Follow Society for Neuroscience on Twitter
  • Follow Society for Neuroscience on LinkedIn
  • Visit Society for Neuroscience on Youtube
  • Follow our RSS feeds

Content

  • Early Release
  • Current Issue
  • Latest Articles
  • Issue Archive
  • Blog
  • Browse by Topic

Information

  • For Authors
  • For the Media

About

  • About the Journal
  • Editorial Board
  • Privacy Notice
  • Contact
  • Feedback
(eNeuro logo)
(SfN logo)

Copyright © 2025 by the Society for Neuroscience.
eNeuro eISSN: 2373-2822

The ideas and opinions expressed in eNeuro do not necessarily reflect those of SfN or the eNeuro Editorial Board. Publication of an advertisement or other product mention in eNeuro should not be construed as an endorsement of the manufacturer’s claims. SfN does not assume any responsibility for any injury and/or damage to persons or property arising from or related to any use of any material contained in eNeuro.