Trends in Neurosciences
Review‘Primitive intelligence’ in the auditory cortex
Section snippets
Central sound representation: underlying sound perception and transient sensory memory
On the basis of a large number of MMN studies, Näätänen and Winkler 6 have concluded that the neural traces involved in MMN generation in the auditory cortex encode the specific sensory information that appears in our auditory perception and sensory memory; that is, they carry the central sound representation (CSR). The authors have further proposed that the transient build-up phase of CSR underlies the perception of a (brief) sound and the slowly decaying phase of CSR the transient sensory
Auditory change detection
The MMN data (reviewed in Box 1) suggest that the auditory cortex maintains the representation of the immediate auditory past. Furthermore, each sound is automatically compared with these representations, and if some of the regularities are violated, then MMN, which represents the difference signal, is generated (see Box 1). This auditory cortex process itself is pre-perceptual but tends to trigger frontal cortex activity (reflected by the frontal MMN subcomponent 7), which probably underlies
Auditory stream formation and segregation
Typically, we receive acoustic information that originates from several simultaneous sound sources. Our central auditory system, therefore, has to segregate this mixture of the concurrent sound streams from each other and to attribute them to their original sources. The pitch, timbre, and location of the origin of the sounds, for example, provide cues used in stream segregation 1, which results in multiple perceptually separate sound streams. This process of assigning sensory inputs to the
Sound object formation
Sussman et al. have demonstrated pre-attentive auditory grouping within a single sound source 14. They presented a repetitive sequence of five tones (AAAAB) at a slow pace to subjects who were ignoring the tones (SOA=1.3 s). MMN was elicited by the frequency-deviant B tone, but it disappeared when the tone sequence was presented at a fast pace (SOA=100 ms). This suggests that the five tones were pre-attentively grouped together as a single perceptual unit, or sound object, when presented at the
Pre-attentive sound anticipation by transient extrapolatory traces
Even when subjects perform a task unrelated to the sound, MMN can be elicited by a steadily descending tone sequence that is interrupted by an ascending tone, and even by tone repetition 15 (Fig. 1). This result suggests that the auditory cortex does not only model the immediate auditory past but also forms extrapolatory traces on the basis of the regularities or trends detected in the auditory past, that is, these traces can represent anticipatory sound events 4, 17.
Extracting abstract sound patterns from the ongoing stimulus sequence
Saarinen et al. presented tone pairs to their subjects when they were reading a book 18. The standards were ascending pairs (that is, rising in frequency from the first to the second tone of the pair), whereas the deviant pairs were descending ones. Maintaining the frequency ratio between the first and second tone of the pairs, they randomly occurred on five different frequency levels, thus forming no physically constant standard pair, but rather a higher-order, ‘abstract’ standard, the
Sound categorization on the basis of relationships between sound attributes
Very recently, Paavilainen et al. found that the pre-attentive sound analysis mechanisms are even capable of extracting invariant abstract relationships between two sound features 21. Their standard stimuli continuously varied over a large range in frequency and intensity, so that there was no physically constant, repetitive standard stimulus or feature conjunction. Instead, the various examplars of the ‘standard’ stimulus obeyed a rule such as ‘the higher the frequency, the louder the
Permanent sound recognition and discrimination
MMN does not only reflect transient sensory traces but also more permanent ones. This is illustrated in Fig. 2, which shows that MMN that is not initially elicited by a change in a complex spectro–temporal pattern, develops in the course of the session, as subjects learn to discriminate these changes 22. It appears that this MMN elicitation is due to the gradual development of an accurate enough representation, or trace, for the complex spectrotemporal pattern. (Consistent with this, the
Categorical sound perception guided by recognition traces (for example, speech perception)
The existence of language-specific memory traces (in the auditory cortex) was demonstrated by Näätänen et al.27 (see also Ref. 28). They found that Finnish subjects’ MMN to an occasional replacement of the repetitive Finnish (and Estonian) vowel /e/ was larger when the deviant sound was a vowel in Finnish (/ö/) than when it was a vowel in Estonian only (/õ/). By contrast, both deviant sounds elicited enhanced MMNs of about equal amplitude in Estonian subjects, in whose mother tongue both are
Concluding remarks
In summary, this article has reviewed MMN (and MMNm) evidence to suggest the existence of different forms of pre-attentive cognitive operations in audition. It is of considerable interest that these cognitive processes occur, mostly, at the level of the auditory cortex (most probably in the secondary and association areas 27, 29, 30) where we can observe these manifestations of primitive sensory level intelligence, such as anticipation of next stimuli, speech sound perception (irrespective of
Acknowledgements
Our research is supported by the Academy of Finland, National Institutes of Health (R55 DC04263), and Hungarian National Research Fund (OTKA T022681).
References (33)
Auditory Scene Analysis: The Perceptual Organization of Sound
(1990)Auditory stream segregation in infancy
Infant Behav. Dev.
(1982)Preattentive extraction of abstract feature conjunctions from auditory stimulation as reflected by the mismatch negativity (MMN)
Psychophysiology
(2001)Development of a memory trace for a complex sound in the human brain
NeuroReport
(1993)Processing of complex sounds in the human auditory cortex as revealed by magnetic brain responses
Psychophysiology
(1996)The perception of speech sounds by the human brain as reflected by the mismatch negativity (MMN) and its magnetic equivalent MMNm
Psychophysiology
(2001)Development of language-specific phoneme representations in the infant brain
Nat. Neurosci.
(1998)Auditory cortex accesses phonological categories: an MEG mismatch study
J. Cogn. Neurosci.
(2000)- et al.
Organization and discrimination of repeating sound sequences by newborn infants
J. Acoust. Soc. Am.
(1997) Adaptive modeling of the unattended acoustic environment reflected in the mismatch negativity event-related potential
Brain Res.
(1996)