Recognition and discrimination of emotional faces and pictures

doi:10.1016/0093-934X(80)90141-8

Brain and Language

Volume 9, Issue 2, March 1980, Pages 206-214

https://doi.org/10.1016/0093-934X(80)90141-8 Get rights and content

Abstract

In order to learn whether patients with right-hemisphere disease (RHD) had a deficit in their ability to discriminate and comprehend emotional faces and pictures, we studied nine patients with RHD, nine patients with left-hemisphere disease (LHD), and nine controls. The subjects were presented with six picture tests that comprised either emotional faces or emotional scenes. Their task was either to denote (name or choose) an emotion or to discriminate (same, different) between two faces or emotions. Patients with RHD performed significantly worse than subjects with LHD when asked to discriminate between faces, to discriminate between emotional faces, and to name emotional scenes. There was also a trend for the RHD group to be more impaired than the LHD group when asked to name the emotional face or choose the emotional face. Except for the facial and emotional discrimination tests, the LHD patients also performed worse than controls.

References (15)

S. Berent
Functional asymmetry of the human brain in the recognition of faces
Neuropsychologia
(1977)
A. Carmon et al.
Ear asymmetry in perception of emotional and nonverbal stimuli
Acta Physiologica
(1973)
G. Gainotti
Emotional behavior and hemispheric side of the lesion
Cortex
(1972)
R.G. Ley et al.
Hemispheric differences in processing emotions and faces
Brain and Language
(1979)
M. Suberi et al.
Differential right hemispheric memory of emotional and non-emotional faces
Neuropsychologia
(1977)
H. Damasio et al.
Anatomic significance of “paradoxic” extinction in dichcotic listening
Neurology (Minneapolis)
(1978)
D. Denny-Brown et al.
The significance of perceptual rivalry resulting from parietal lesions
Brain
(1952)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (244)

Some historical notes orienting towards brain mechanisms that could underlie hemispheric asymmetries
2023, Cortex
The first minor aim of this synthetical historical survey consisted in showing that the discovery of the internal organization of language within the left hemisphere has been mainly determined by theoretical models and cultural factors, whereas the discovery of the left lateralisation of language and of the right lateralization of emotions and of other cognitive and perceptual functions has been mainly determined by empirical observations.
A second more relevant aim of the survey consisted in discussing historical and more recent data suggesting that the different lateralisation of language and emotions has influenced not only the asymmetrical representation of other cognitive, affective and perceptual functions, but also (thank to the shaping influence of language on human cognition) of asymmetries regarding more general aspects of thought (such as the distinctions between ‘propositional vs automatic’ and ‘conscious vs unconscious’ ways of functioning).
In the last part of the review, these data will be included in a more general discussion, concerning the brain functions that could be subsumed by the right hemisphere for three main reasons: (a) to avoid conflicts with the language mediated activities of the left hemisphere; (b) because of unconscious and automatic aspects of its non-verbal organisation or (c) due to the competition for cortical space determined by the development of language within the left hemisphere.
Psychiatric sequelae of stroke affecting the non-dominant cerebral hemisphere
2021, Journal of the Neurological Sciences
There are a plethora of cognitive sequelae in addition to neglect and extinction that arise with unilateral right hemispheric stroke (RHS). Cognitive deficits following non-dominant (right) hemisphere stroke are common with unilateral neglect and extinction being the most recognized examples. The severity of RHS is usually underestimated by the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS), which in terms of lateralized right hemisphere cognitive deficits, tests only for visual inattention/extinction. They account for 2 out of 42 total possible points. Additional neuropsychiatric sequelae include but are not limited to deficiencies in affective prosody comprehension and production (aprosodias), understanding and expressing facial emotions, empathy, recognition of familiar faces, anxiety, mania, apathy, and psychosis. These sequelae have a profound impact on patients' quality of life; affecting communication, interpersonal relationships, and the ability to fulfill social roles. They also pose additional challenges to recovery. There is presently a gap in the literature regarding a cohesive overview of the significant cognitive sequelae following RHS. This paper serves as a narrative survey of the current understanding of the subject, with particular emphasis on neuropsychiatric poststroke syndromes not predominantly associated with left hemisphere lesions (LHL), bilateral lesions, hemiplegia, or paralysis. A more comprehensive understanding of the neuropsychological consequences of RHS extending beyond the typical associations of unilateral neglect and extinction may have important implications for clinical practice, including the ways in which clinicians approach diagnostics, treatment, and rehabilitation.
Disorders of facial emotional expression and comprehension
2021, Handbook of Clinical Neurology
One of the most important means of communicating emotions is by facial expressions. About 30–40 years ago, several studies examined patients with right and left hemisphere strokes for deficits in expressing and comprehending emotional facial expressions. The participants with right- or left-hemispheric strokes attempted to determine if two different actors were displaying the same or different emotions, to name the different emotions being displayed, and to select the face displaying an emotion named by the examiner. Investigators found that the right hemisphere-damaged group was impaired on all these emotional facial tests and that this deficit was not solely related to visuoperceptual processing defects. Further studies revealed that the patients who were impaired at recognizing emotional facial expressions and who had lost these visual representations of emotional faces often had damage to their right parietal lobe and their right somatosensory cortex. Injury to the cerebellum has been reported to impair emotional facial recognition, as have dementing diseases such as Alzheimer's disease and frontotemporal dementia, movement disorders such as Parkinson's disease and Huntington's disease, traumatic brain injuries, and temporal lobe epilepsy.
Patients with right hemisphere injury are also more impaired than left-hemisphere-damaged patients when attempting to voluntarily produce facial emotional expressions and in their spontaneous expression of emotions in response to stimuli. This impairment does not appear to be induced by emotional conceptual deficits or an inability to experience emotions. Many of the disorders that cause impairments of comprehension of affective facial expressions also impair facial emotional expression.
Treating the underlying disease may help patients with impairments of facial emotion recognition and expression, but unfortunately, there have not been many studies of rehabilitation.
Hemispheric stroke: Mood disorders
2021, Handbook of Clinical Neurology
Stroke causes many forms of disability, including emotional and mood disorders. Depression is the most common of these, affecting approximately one-third of stroke patients. Other disorders like mania, bipolar disorder, anxiety disorder, or apathy may also develop following stroke, although they are less common. The development of mood and emotional disorders is dependent on the severity of brain injury, the side of injury, and hemispheric location. Whereas a left hemispheric stroke often results in depression or a catastrophic reaction with anxiety, injury to the right hemisphere has predominantly been associated with the development of emotional indifference (anosodiaphoria) or euphoria. In this chapter, we discuss the mood disorders associated with hemispheric strokes and the neuropsychological mechanisms that might account for the clinical manifestations of these affective disorders.
Emotional Semantic Congruency based on stimulus driven comparative judgements
2019, Cognition
A common cognitive process in everyday life consists in the comparative judgements of emotions given a pair of facial expressions and the choice of the most positive/negative among them. Results from three experiments on complete-facial expressions (happy/angry) and mixed-facial expressions (neutral/happy-or-angry) pairs viewed with (Experiment 1 and 3) or without (Experiment 2) foveation and performed in conditions in which valence was either task relevant (Experiment 1 and 2) or task irrelevant (Experiment 3), show that comparative judgements of emotions are stimulus driven. Judgements' speed increased as the target absolute emotion intensity grew larger together with the average emotion of the pair, irrespective of the compatibility between the valence and the side of motor response: a semantic congruency effect in the domain of emotion. This result undermines previous interpretation of results in the context of comparative judgements based on the lateralization of emotions (e.g., SNARC-like instructional flexibility), and is fully consistent with our formalization of emotional semantic congruency: the direct Speed-Intensity Association model.
TMS demonstrates that both right and left superior temporal sulci are important for facial expression recognition
2018, NeuroImage
Citation Excerpt :
This functional asymmetry of the face-responsive pSTS suggests that expression recognition may be preferentially processed in the right hemisphere (Narumoto et al., 2001). Such a hypothesis is consistent with an earlier neuropsychological study in which patients with lesions in the right hemisphere were significantly worse in performing tasks using emotional faces than patients with left-hemispheric lesions (DeKosky et al., 1980). A right hemisphere advantage was also demonstrated by the left visual field superiority for the recognition of emotional facial expressions in healthy individuals (Sackeim et al., 1978).
Prior studies demonstrate that a face-responsive region in the posterior superior temporal sulcus (pSTS) is involved in facial expression recognition. Although this region can be identified in both hemispheres, studies more commonly report it in the right hemisphere. However, the extent to which expression recognition is lateralised in pSTS remains unclear. In the current study, we used transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to systematically compare the causal contribution of the right pSTS (rpSTS) with the left pSTS (lpSTS) during facial expression recognition. TMS was delivered over the functionally localised rpSTS, lpSTS and the control vertex site while participants (N = 30) performed an expression matching task and a control object matching task. TMS delivered over the rpSTS impaired expression recognition more than TMS delivered over the lpSTS. Crucially, TMS delivered over the rpSTS and lpSTS impaired task performance more than TMS delivered over the control site. TMS had no effect on the control task. This causally demonstrates that while task disruption was greater in the rpSTS, both the rpSTS and the lpSTS were engaged in facial expression recognition. Our results indicate that cognitive functions that are seemingly lateralised in neuroimaging studies, still rely on computations performed in both hemispheres for optimum task performance.

View all citing articles on Scopus

^☆: This research was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Grant 5 RO1 NS12218-01 A2. This paper was presented, in part to the World Federation of Neurology, Research Group of Aphasiology, Iowa City, Iowa, October 13, 1978.

View full text

Recognition and discrimination of emotional faces and pictures☆

Abstract

Neuropsychologia

Acta Physiologica

Cortex

Brain and Language

Neuropsychologia

Anatomic significance of “paradoxic” extinction in dichcotic listening

Neurology (Minneapolis)

The significance of perceptual rivalry resulting from parietal lesions

Brain